Roe vs Wade and origin of the abortion debate

The emotional, religious and political debate surrounding abortion has a long history, of which Roe Vs Wade is just one defining aspect.

By Rachel Segal

How the Pro Choice camp sees it
How the Pro Life camp sees it
First U.S. Law Passed Restricting Abortion

Connecticut regrettably passes the first law in the United States to restrict abortion. This law, which oppressively reflects the anti-abortion British common law, prohibits a woman from using poison to cause a miscarriage after “quickening,” or the start of fetal movements, usually during the fourth month of pregnancy.

Connecticut’s welcome law barring abortions after quickening, the first of its kind in the independent United States, sets a necessary and vital precedent for the future direction of the country. Fortunately,  a number of other states soon follow suit, protecting fetuses but also women from ill-trained abortionists.

First National Campaign Launches against Abortion

To the horror of married protestant couples in America, among whom induced abortion is common practice for unwanted pregnancies, Dr. Horatio Storer launches a national anti-abortion crusade by brainwashing physicians in the American Medical Association to refuse to grant abortions. Unfortunately, his self-righteous and meddling campaign eventually leads to all abortions becoming illegal.

Dr. Horatio Storer’s enlightened campaign aimed at educating both physicians and pregnant patients about the physical evils of abortion puts a necessary stop to the frequent induced abortions being performed at this time. Using his gynecological expertise and knowledge, he convinces female patients that unjustifiable abortion of fetal life is a crime and that they should continue with their pregnancies.

Congress Passes Comstock Law

Congress gravely violates individuals’ rights to privacy and, even worse, limits women’s reproductive rights by passing the Comstock Law. This law signifies government censorship and overreach by prohibiting the selling or distributing of information and materials related to abortion, pornography or contraception.

The Comstock Law is essential for ensuring a much-needed nationwide spiritual revival. By banning the dissemination by mail of information on abortion, pornography or artificial contraceptives, this law prevents such obscene materials from being used to further corrupt public morals and decency.

Predecessor to Planned Parenthood Founded

After opening the first birth control clinic in the United States – and getting arrested for distributing information about contraception – the admired Margaret Sanger establishes the American Birth Control League, which later becomes Planned Parenthood Federation of America. Her bold efforts to legalize contraception was a helpful way for women to avoid situations that led to abortion.

While Margaret Sanger is widely frowned upon for anti-Catholic sentiments and her controversial views of race and eugenics, she surprisingly is not in favor of abortion.  While her Planned Parenthood organization started offering abortion in the 1960s, she, herself, should be credited for promoting contraception as an alternative to abortion and even turning away clients seeking abortion.

Abortion during the Great Depression

The devastating economic situation during the Great Depression, coupled with the crippling lack of access to contraception, leads to a rise in illegal abortions. Both married mothers who can’t afford another child and unmarried women who can’t afford to marry are forced to seek illegal abortions as their only solution for survival.

As proof of the evils of abortion, in 1931, illegal abortions lead to 14% of maternal deaths. It is an especially painful era for women, who are unfortunately slow to understand that, no matter their economic standing, no situation can be bad enough to warrant a needless, cruel and dangerous procedure.

First Abortion Rights Activist Speaks Out

Pat Maginnis courageously establishes the Society for Humane Abortion, which advocates for elective abortions. She becomes one of the first women in America to publicly campaign for legalizing abortion, and she and her “Army of Three” bravely canvass for a woman’s right to have access to abortion providers in an effort to combat the assault on women’s health rights.

While Pat Maginnis claims to promote women’s rights, she is doing a blatant disservice to women and humanity by promoting killing as a solution to what is clearly a social problem. Many pro-life organizations concentrate their efforts on spreading messages in church circles and the public that adoption is a real solution and that there is no shortage of couples looking to adopt

Sherri Finkbine Inspires Abortion Reform Movement

Abortion was never about power or politics but about specific lives. This becomes evident when Arizona mother, Sherri Finkbine, personalizes the need for legalizing abortion after local hospitals deny her request to have one. She is seeking an abortion after finding out that the prescription sleeping pills she had been taking while pregnant were unknowingly linked to birth defects. Finkbine is forced to travel to Sweden for the procedure.

Arizona law is humane, justified and commendable in ruling that the therapeutic abortion Sherri Finkbine was trying to get was illegal. As her life was not at risk from the sleeping pills she had taken, there is no justification for her selfishly wanting to end her unborn child’s life.  This sends an important and necessary message to other young women who may be considering abortion.

December 13, 1971
Supreme Court Hears Roe vs. Wade

Pregnant with her third child and distraught at being prohibited from access to a legal abortion in Texas, the unmarried 21-year-old Norma McCorvey (later known as “Jane Roe”) is referred to attorneys in Dallas. After 3 years of challenging Texas state law, which prohibits abortion except to save a life, the Supreme Court agrees to hear the historic case, which fights for her right to an abortion performed by a competent, licensed physician under safe, clinical conditions.

 Following several trials and a federal district court case that declares as unconstitutional the Texas law prohibiting abortion except to save a woman’s life, the Supreme Court egregiously agrees to hear the Roe vs. Wade case. It is a disastrous decision that threatens to change the abortion debate forever, as the court gives legitimacy to abortionists and cold-blooded murder.

January 22, 1973
Supreme Court Issues Roe V. Wade Ruling

The historic Supreme Court decision affirms a woman’s legal right to an abortion during the entirety of the pregnancy, as it falls within the right to privacy, which is protected under the US Constitution’s 14th Amendment.  This momentous decision makes all previous state abortion laws unconstitutional, an extraordinary achievement for women’s rights.

The catastrophic Roe v. Wade Supreme Court decision strikes down all state laws that had previously made abortion illegal. It signifies that at no point during the pregnancy is the unborn child protected by law, and erroneously views an unborn child as merely a potential person. Granting women the inhumane right to terminate pregnancies for any reason will have grave consequences.

September 14, 2004
Courts Dismiss Motion to Overturn Roe V Wade

After being brainwashed by the pro-life movement, Norma McCorvey (Jane Roe) changes her views on abortion. Claiming that she was naïvely duped by her lawyers into becoming the posterchild for their pre-determined legal mission, she betrays the pro-choice movement by filing a court motion to have Roe V. Wade overturned. This motion is obviously dismissed.

Upon serious reflection, Norma McCorvey comes to understand that she had been ignorant about the implications of abortion throughout the trial, and that her lawyers took advantage of her naiveté for their own ends. Striving to rectify the situation, she learns more about abortion from a pro-life group, which changes her views. She bravely challenges the calamitous Roe V. Wade decision, asking the courts to consider important new evidence that confirms that abortion hurts women. She is unjustifiably dismissed.

Uptick in National Pro-Life Movement

A women’s right to choose is everyone’s responsibility, not just feminists. Despite pervasive efforts by the ever-growing pro-life movement, Congress is able to succeed in narrowly passing healthcare reform that has the potential for tax-payer funded abortions.

For the first time, a majority of Americans (51%) identify themselves as being pro-life with respect to the abortion debate, according to a Gallup poll. Sadly, this crusade of what’s morally right fails to influence government policies.

Trump Threatens to Defund Planned Parenthood

President Trump’s dangerous ultimatum to Planned Parenthood – halt abortions or lose $500 million in annual federal funding – will harm women, as the funds are only used for women’s health services, not abortion.

Heeding the voices of those who voted him into the White House, President Trump shows his support for the pro-life movement by threatening to stop allocating annual federal funding to Planned Parenthood unless it stops providing abortions.

States Pass More Restrictive Abortion Laws

Personal freedom is at stake, as numerous US states are passing archaic laws that ban abortions before women even know they are pregnant. Alabama’s vote to ban abortion in almost all circumstances defies women the basic right to choose what happens to their own bodies. Many of these states, including Ohio and Georgia, don’t make exceptions for cases of rape, which is shameful.

In a welcome shift across America, eight states have taken the lead in fighting to recapture morality by passing the most restrictive abortion laws in generations. Alabama, Ohio, Kentucky, Missouri, Georgia, Mississippi, Utah and Arkansas have all passed laws ranging from fetal heartbeat bans to near total bans on abortion. More states are considering similar measures.


Photo Credits:

  1. poison. 8th June 1875: A safety container for poison with a skull in relief so the bottle cannot be mistaken by accident, blind people or children. Designed by William M Caterson, patent no. 164265. (Photo by M J Rivise Patent Collection/Getty Images
  2. 19th century married couple. circa 1865: A pampered victorian husband relaxes in his dressing gown and hat while his wife lights his pipe with a taper. London Stereoscopic Company Comic Series (Photo by London Stereoscopic Company/Getty Images)
  3. 19th century police. 1887: A Black Maria or secure vehicle used by the police to transport prisoners. Original Artist: By Renouard. Original Publication: The Graphic – pub. 1887 (Photo by Hulton Archive/Getty Images)
  4. Margaret Sanger. Credit: Photo by General Photographic Agency/Getty Images
  5. Strain on women. The wife of a migratory labourer with three children in Texas during the Depression. (Photo by Dorothea Lange/Getty Images)
  6. Pro-Choice March. 1977: Women taking part in a demonstration in New York demanding safe legal abortions for all women. (Photo by Peter Keegan/Keystone/Getty Images)
  7. Sherri Finkbine. American television host Sherri Finkbine and her husband Robert Finkbine arrive in Sweden, August 7, 1962. Sherri Finkbine traveled to Sweden to receive an abortion after discovering that the drug thalidomide caused birth defects. (Photo by Express Newspapers/Getty Images)
  8. Pro-Choice March. 1977: Women taking part in a demonstration in New York demanding safe legal abortions for all women. (Photo by Peter Keegan/Keystone/Getty Images)
  9. Anti-Abortion Man. 5th July 1973: An anti-abortion protestor at a demonstration in front of the American Hotel in mid-town New York, where the American Medical Association is holding its annual convention. The US Supreme Court has ruled that it is a woman’s right to have an abortion if she wishes it. (Photo by Peter Keegan/Keystone/Getty Images)
  10. Regret Abortions. Demonstrators stand in front of the U.S. Supreme Court on January 18, 2005 in Washington, DC. Norma McCorvey, along with the Justice Foundation are petitioning the Supreme Court to reverse it’s decision in Roe v. Wade. (Photo by Travis Lindquist/Getty Images)
  11. Pro-life uptick. JANUARY 24: Pro-life activists hold signs outside the U.S. Supreme Court during the ‘March for Life’ event January 24, 2005 in Washington, DC. The annual anti-abortion march marked the 32nd anniversary of the landmark Roe Vs Wade ruling that legalized abortion. (Photo by Alex Wong/Getty Images)
  12. Defund Planned Parenthood. Pro-Life protestor Rose Ann Schienle of Colorado Springs, Colorado holds a sign while demonstrating outside of the Colorado Springs Westside Health Center February 11, 2017 in Colorado Springs, Colorado. The protest is part of nationwide demonstrations that were held at Planned Parenthood locations in more than 200 cities in an attempt to raise support for restricting women’s ability to have abortions in the United States. (Photo by Marc Piscotty/Getty Images)
Write a response...
See what else you’re missing
modal image