Japanese decluttering expert Marie Kondo has taken root worldwide. Her two hit shows on Netflix and her best-selling books have followers around the world discarding everything that does not “spark joy” and steering clear of buying organizing equipment. Over the years, as she has built up her $8M decluttering empire, followers and detractors alike have often asked whether the KonMari Method truly transforms lives or is it an unrealistic and overwhelming approach to orderly living. Her recent public admission that she had “kind of given up” on keeping her own home tidy has also heated up the debate about whether the professional Queen of Decluttering’s method is worth all the hype.
Here are three reasons why Kondo’s method works and three why it doesn’t.
Three reasons Marie Kondo’s philosophy is wonderful
Allows for quick and concrete results
Marie Kondo writes that “when we disperse storage of a particular item throughout the house and tidy one place at a time, we can never grasp the overall volume and therefore can never finish.” As such, her philosophy declares that decluttering your space must be done comprehensively and all at once. This way, objective results can be obtained, driving future upkeep. Otherwise, the tidying process would never be completed. This, in turn, creates a sense that the work is never-ending, which can lead to a subsequent lack of motivation. Sometimes, people need a new approach to tidying up to drive real change. Though extremely intensive, the KonMari Method may help accomplish this task as it forces you to transform your space quickly.
Teaches better appreciation for belongings – and yourself
People tend to ascribe more value to items, simply because they own(ed) them. Adhering to Kondo’s philosophy, asking yourself “What sparks joy?” acknowledges your belongings’ usefulness. It also teaches you to show gratitude to those objects that bring you joy, which, in turn, provides insight into what you value, which will help decide what to keep. This method takes the form of physical and mental decluttering, giving you a greater appreciation for everything you have in life. It can also influence future life choices, purchasing patterns and can enable you to acquire only what you need from a place of greater clarity. The KonMari Method has the potential to prevent physical and psychological clutter from resurfacing later by teaching you what you truly value.
Sorting belongings by category better clarifies your needs
Kondo’s philosophy stipulates that belongings should be sorted by category, like shoes or toiletries, instead of by room. Then, for each category, you are supposed to gather all relevant items from around the house and sort them together, all at once. This method allows you to remain within context and thereby make focused decisions on what exactly you need. For example, you might not need three English-Finnish dictionaries, but if you decluttered room-by-room instead of by category, you may never realize you’d bought this item in triplicate. Adhering to Kondo’s category-based decluttering model also saves time previously spent looking for items around the home. Once the tidying process is complete, this extra time can be used for personal growth, quality time with friends and family or blissful idleness.
Three reasons Marie Kondo’s philosophy is shortsighted
Decluttering is a process, not a ‘one and done’ event
For many, there is no such thing as a singular decluttering project, after which clutter never resurfaces. Yet, this is a tenet of the KonMari Method. People buy new items, store them inappropriately, forget purchases, regret purchases and launch new decluttering operations. It’s human nature. The concept that people tidy once and never have to tidy again, even after acquiring new belongings, is unrealistic for most people. Such a philosophy expects too much of people; such a commitment to the process of tidying up takes energy and time; if it is abandoned halfway through or left unfinished, it may leave people feeling worse about themselves and their home than when they started.
The one-size-fits-all philosophy doesn’t really fit everyone
Marie Kondo wrote her guide as a single woman in her early thirties, living in a small Japanese apartment. As such, American readers should consider that Japanese men and women living in micro apartments with inadequate storage space may mull acquisitions more than the average American. This could also mean that the KonMari Method would be more effective for people living in Japan than for people living in America. Therefore, people living in large spaces or with many family members and/or roommates, such as families with multiple children, may not realistically benefit from her decluttering philosophy. Tidying an entire home in one go or sorting through the belongings of six family members according to category may end up being confusing and ineffective.
Not all items spark joy – but we still need them
Shopping is called retail therapy for a reason. Studies have shown that the gratifying effects of shopping cause your brain to release more of the feel-good chemical serotonin. But this does not mean that acquiring or possessing all items “spark joy.” Sometimes you simply need items for practical reasons. You absolutely need a drawer full of underwear or outgrown baby clothes, or you may have to hold onto bags of pipe cleaners and markers for your kids. Are you happier because you own these items? No, but you can’t do away with them either.
The Bottom Line: While Marie Kondo’s philosophy does contain some good advice, it is definitely not full-proof. Discovering the decluttering method that fits your lifestyle is quite individual and may require some trial and error. So, will you be trying out the KonMari Method?