formats back

Proud recipient of the following awards:

Should Churches and Religious Organizations be Taxed?

By Emma Saven
 Unsplash

Churches and religious organizations have experienced tax exemptions for centuries, dating back to the Roman Empire, when Emperor Constantine exempted the Christian church from taxation in the 4th century. In the United States and many other Western countries, churches and other religious institutions remain exempt from income taxes, while donations are often eligible for tax deductions.

Other nations, including Germany, Italy, Sweden, and Denmark, shifted gears by collecting church taxes from members to help fund religious institutions. Despite growing disaffiliation in more Western nations today, these policies remain widespread and continue to invite questions about whether religious tax privileges still make sense in the modern world. 

 

#TaxTheChurches

 

Churches enjoy major tax benefits, yet face less financial scrutiny than other nonprofits. 

Most Churches are exempt from filing the annual IRS Form 990. In simple words, they are generally not expected to disclose detailed information about their income, expenses, executive compensation, or how donations are being used to the public. Because of this, it becomes more difficult for donors, taxpayers, and regulators to determine whether tax-exempt organizations are actually using their resources for charitable or religious purposes, rather than exploiting their status for financial abuse or misuse. If there is a lack of routine financial oversight, this creates the opportunity for the lack of accountability to fester. A church/religious organization could build impressive wealth, own valuable property, or spend large amounts of money without facing the same level of financial transparency and accountability expected of comparable secular nonprofits.

 

Defining a “legitimate” church can make tax exemptions a legal minefield

What are the lines around creating a new belief, finding like-minded followers, calling it a “church” and claiming a tax break? Blurred. When it comes to understanding exactly what constitutes a legitimate faith, people are having a field day. In an ABCs 2010 news report, Oklahoma granted tax-exempt status to a Satanist Group. The Church of Scientology offers another strong example. Despite facing major criticism and being labeled by TIME as a “thriving cult of greed and power,” the organization earned federal tax-exempt status in 1993. According to The New York Times, the exemption ultimately saved the church tens of millions of dollars in taxes. In Australia’s latest census, more than 50,000 people recorded their religion as “Jedi.” So, if someone established a Jedi Church, would it qualify for the same tax-exempt status as other religious organizations?  If any belief system can qualify as a religion, automatic tax exemptions for churches become difficult to justify and even harder to police. 

 

Tax exemptions for houses of worship leave less money for public services

When churches and other houses of worship are exempt from property taxes, local governments give up revenue that could go toward public services. According to the New York City Department of Finance, the city’s religious property tax exemptions were worth $867.1 million in fiscal year 2025. In the same fiscal year, Washington, D.C., estimated that it would forgo about $73 million in property tax revenue through its exemption for churches, synagogues, and mosques. Even if the city collected only a portion of that amount, it could put that money toward public schools, libraries, or emergency services. Some religious organizations help support their communities through food pantries, shelters, and other programs. However, those contributions still don’t justify a tax exemption of this size, especially when the revenue could help fund services that the wider community relies on.

 

Keep The Taxman out of The Houses of Worship 

 

A tax bill would bring unwanted government influence into religious affairs

A strong separation between government and religious institutions is essential in preventing unnecessary government involvement in religion. In Walz v. Tax Commission (1970), the Supreme Court upheld property-tax exemptions for religious organizations, addressing that taxing churches would create a closer, potentially intrusive, relationship between government and religion. Taxation could require officials to assess church property, impose tax liens, or even pursue foreclosures when taxes aren’t paid, creating ongoing government oversight of religious institutions. Consider how that could play out locally. A church lets residents use its meeting hall to organize against the mayor’s redevelopment plan. When the church falls behind on its property taxes, the mayor’s office hints that it could pursue a tax lien if the meetings continue. Church leaders are left weighing whether to keep the hall open to their neighbors or risk a lien on their property.

 

 

If the tax bill comes, the community pays the price 

Most churches offer substantial social services that benefit their communities. According to research conducted, it was found that 83% of U.S. congregations participate in some form of social or human-service activity, including providing food, clothing, housing assistance, and health-related support. Churches are especially active in providing food assistance: one study found that 48% of U.S. congregations, more than 150,000 congregations, operated or supported a food-distribution program. These services grant churches the ability to address poverty and hardship by using private donations and volunteers rather than leaning heavily on government funding. Therefore, tax exemptions allow for religious organizations to prioritize their financial resources on supporting the community, rather than on taxes, especially when they can show that their work delivers tangible benefits to the public. 

 

Houses of worship should be treated like comparable nonprofits

A historical society can qualify for a property tax exemption on a building it uses as a museum. Why should a church lose that same exemption on a building it uses for worship? New York City, for example, considers how a nonprofit uses its property when deciding whether it qualifies. A building used for worship can qualify under the same framework as one used for education, charity, or historic preservation. The same question arises with federal income taxes. A church can end the year with money left over, but like other nonprofits that qualify under Section 501(c)(3), it cannot pass those earnings on to private owners. If it regularly runs a business unrelated to its religious purpose, the income from that business can still be taxed. So if the concern is that a church is making money from a commercial activity, why take away the exemption for the building where its congregation gathers to worship?

The bottom line: Ultimately, the discussion of taxing churches often feels like a game of chess, with both sides in checkmate. Taxing religious institutions may improve accountability, but it could also increase government influence in religion and reduce funding for community services. The debate comes down to whether tax revenue is more valuable than the services and support churches provide. 

 

Advertisement
SHOW COMMENTS
Write a response...
See what else you’re missing